There is a lot of junk floating around on the Internet and in the media regarding the Sony Pictures breach. Who did it? What were the motives? These are all being violently discussed in the Twitter-sphere and elsewhere, and if you happen to read the articles and blogs being churned out by the media your head is probably spinning right now.
While I don't think we (the public) generally know enough to be able to talk about the breach with any certainty yet - and perhaps we never will - there is an critical point here which I think is being missed.
What is the lesson the public should take away from the breach, and subsequent consequences?
Why nearly everyone has focused on the circus surrounding the breach itself - including the celebrity dirty laundry going public, un-released movies being leaked to bit torrent download sites, and the truckload of everything you never want to get out that's been dumped to the Internet - there is very little focus being given to the thing (or things) that we should all be taking away from this breach.
By now everyone should agree breaches are inevitable, and continuing to pour money into the black hole that is prevention is ridiculous. Let me be clear, I'm not saying to spend nothing on prevention, I'm simply pointing out the continuing folly of pouring ever more money and resources into prevention which we know will fail. So this can't be the lesson.
We all also know that segmentation of duties, data and processes should be a key point in every security program. We've been learning this lesson for almost 20 years now - and I can't help but feel that this push to an even faster delivery of IT services has made segmentation and segregation a near impossibility in many large enterprises. I've watched CISOs try to leverage tools, network architectures, system re-designs and even cloud services -- much in vain as the result is data, processes and duties of all levels of risk end up in a big free-for-all. So, again, this isn't the lesson to learn.
Should the lesson be that we much not poke the bear? I mean, let's face it, if you look at this objectively outside the limited American viewpoint - Sony Pictures did antagonize North Korea quite a bit. Then again, recent information made public by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has indicated that North Korea was in fact not the perpetrator of this breach. So maybe poking the bear isn't the problem, and anyway this is a lesson we as humans should learn in Kindergarten not in the corporate world.
So if you're still reading then like me you may be searching for a so what? moment. And to be honest, I am struggling to provide one. So maybe it's not one thing that we need to learn but a much bigger set of things together. Maybe it's a lesson in humility, communications, planning, execution, operational efficiency, and crisis response all rolled into a heaping pile pushed down the hill and lit on fire. Maybe the bigger lesson we need to learn is that it's not one thing that we need to get right - but rather all of them have to just work well together, and be planned, practiced and tuned.
I seriously doubt anyone out there is planning and practicing for the kind of disaster Sony Pictures is facing right now. If every single piece of intellectual and secret property (including employee records, confidential communications, financials of all kinds, and more) you have was made public - where would you start to recover? Getting your IT systems back online is a good start, but that doesn't mean you can recover your business when your employees, partners, vendors, and customers are banging on your door demanding answers and action.
Maybe that's it then, maybe the lesson is that you can't always package up a lesson learned neatly with a bow based on someone's catastrophic incident. I think it's clear we all can be set ablaze in this manner. If it's not then it should be. So the question I pose to you is this - what's your take-away from the Sony Pictures catastrophe?
As a side note, many people and articles have taken to calling this an "unprecedented" breach. I am inclined to agree but not for the technical reasons that are being rattled off. It's not because the method of attack was novel, or that there was likely an insider, or even the quantity and quality of the assets that were stolen - or heck even that everything is being made public in an embarrassment to the company. No I think this is unprecedented because we're seeing company executives apologizing to political leaders, civil rights activists fanning race-war flames with some of the email content published, and as one article put it "Sony is a pariah in Hollywood" right now. Folks - that's not good. This is a meltdown of a brutal nature the likes I don't believe we've seen before. This is a PR catastrophe.
As always, I'm interested in your thoughts... leave a comment, or hit me on Twitter.